Panini America Appreciates $29,889 Worth of Tom Brady’s Football Card Majesty

53,2358 passing yards. 392 career touchdown passes. 160 regular-season wins. 12 AFC East championships. Six AFC titles. Four Super Bowl rings. Three Super Bowl MVP awards. More touchdown passes . . . and passing yards . . . and completions . . . and attempts than any player in Super Bowl history. Indeed, when it comes to the on-field accolades that matter most to expert NFL analysts, New England Patriots superstar Tom Brady has them all. And because he does, the 199th player selected in the 2000 NFL Draft also has most of the accolades that matter in the sports-card world, too. Brady's 2000 Contenders Football Rookie Card is a bona fide collecting icon that means as much to the modern era as, say, Mickey Mantle or Babe Ruth RCs mean to the vintage arena. And to think, that now-landmark Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph -- card No. 144 on your checklist -- started out as little more than afterthought filler when it released in January of 2001. The first published value for that card appeared in the the March 2001 issue of Beckett Football: $20.

Panini America Tom Brady 5995

53,2358 passing yards. 392 career touchdown passes. 160 regular-season wins. 12 AFC East championships. Six AFC titles. Four Super Bowl rings. Three Super Bowl MVP awards. More touchdown passes . . . and passing yards . . . and completions . . . and attempts than any player in Super Bowl history. Indeed, when it comes to the on-field accolades that matter most to expert NFL analysts, New England Patriots superstar Tom Brady has them all. And because he does, the 199th player selected in the 2000 NFL Draft also has most of the accolades that matter in the sports-card world, too.

Brady’s 2000 Contenders Football Rookie Card is a bona fide collecting icon that means as much to the modern era as, say, Mickey Mantle or Babe Ruth RCs mean to the vintage arena. And to think, that now-landmark Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph — card No. 144 on your checklist — started out as little more than afterthought filler when it released in January of 2001. The first published value for that card appeared in the the March 2001 issue of Beckett Football: $20.

Today, that card, which ascended to an unfathomable peak value of $1,600 in late 2007, is valued by Beckett Media at $1,000 — but it often sells for more than that. The Championship Ticket parallel version limited to just 100 copies is valued at $3,000 — but a BGS 8.5 example sold for $4,999 earlier this week, a transaction no doubt fueled by Brady’s masterful performance against the Seattle Seahawks in last Sunday’s Super Bowl XLIX victory.

But even that staggering sale pales in comparison to the $5,999 asking price for Brady’s 2014 Flawless Football Flawless Patches Autographs Platinum 1/1 — Brady’s “best auto patch card in the hobby” according to the eBay listing. (That card was originally listed in mid January and appeared to sell for $5,995, but the original seller recently relisted it.) Clearly, much has changed for Brady — on the field and in the hobby — since his days as a fourth-fiddle rookie who barely made New England’s final roster coming out of his rookie training camp.

Fifteen years later, the seventh quarterback selected in the 2000 NFL Draft (behind Chad Pennington, Giovanni Carmazzi, Chris Redman, Tee Martin, Marc Bulger and Spurgeon Wynn) is largely considered the greatest quarterback selected in any NFL Draft. As a result, his best Panini America trading cards are treated — and coveted — like priceless artifacts.

In the staggering showcase that follows, we honor the Patriots’ legendary No. 12 by profiling 19 Brady cards — new and old — that have sold on eBay in recent weeks. Collectively, the cards represent $29,889 worth of “Wow!” — which just might be the best way to sum up the career of one of the greatest quarterbacks we’ve ever seen.

Values used in the gallery above were taken from closed eBay auctions. We’ve used images of the actual cards sold whenever possible; in some instances we used pre-release images of the actual cards or better-quality images of cards from the same sets.

Share

0 Replies to “Panini America Appreciates $29,889 Worth of Tom Brady’s Football Card Majesty”

  1. Definitely some awesome cards!

    It is curious to think though, and I’d love your input Tracy! Brady was coming up at a time when there weren’t a ton of autograph cards, let alone rookie autograph cards. Do you think in this era when a guy like Andrew Luck or Russell Wilson have thousands of autograph cards out, there is still room for long term value? Obviously if those continue to succeed there will be some value, but when there’s just so many out there, it seems like the bottom has to drop out somewhere?

    You show a ruby Flawless patch auto of Tom Brady above that sold for $1,500, but checking ebay sold listing, Peyton Mannings just like it sold for for around $275. You can argue that it’s because Brady is better than Manning, but I think a more accurate argument is that Manning just signs so much more often than Brady, that it waters down the market and affects the value a great deal.

    Sorry, don’t mean to hijack this post, I was just wondering how you feel about that?

    Thanks!

    1. No hijack at all. Appreciate the conversation. Scarcity absolutely has a lot to do with it; the overall availability of a player’s autograph definitely impacts his overall value. But Brady’s stuff is relatively limited and when you combine that with all-time-great production, you tend to get crazy values. I think it can be argued that if Manning had another ring or two, the values of his best cards would be more in line with the best ever.

      But there will always be demand for the iconic players and when supply is more easily met, the values will certainly indicate that.

      1. Very cool of you to respond! Thanks!

        And yeah, I suppose that’s where the fine line of collector vs investor comes into play. As strictly a collector, I am thrilled to be able to add some nice autographs to my collection for a good price, so I’m not complaining!

        Make sure you put out more and more Rod Woodson on-card autographs so I can pick one of those up for a good price! 😉

  2. Every collector who opens Panini football products like seeing that Patriots logo on their hits, hoping for a card like the gallery above to add to their collection or pass along to a Tom Brady/Pats fan at a sizable profit. Excellent article on this hobby trend, thanks Tracy!

Leave a Reply to Andy Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *